In Islamic studies, the term madhhab is used in two main contexts: one related to practice and law, and the other related to belief and theology. Understanding the distinction between these two is essential for properly grasping differences within Islam.
---
1. What Is a Juristic School (Fiqh Madhhab)?
A juristic school refers to a systematic body of opinions and methodologies used to derive practical Islamic rulings, such as prayer, fasting, pilgrimage, transactions, and other legal matters.
Key features:
Focus: Practical religious acts and laws
Sources: The Qur’an, Sunnah, consensus (ijmāʿ), and reason (with methodological differences)
Differences mainly occur in secondary rulings (furūʿ al-dīn)
Following a juristic school is necessary for correct religious practice
Examples:
Jaʿfarī
Ḥanafī
Shāfiʿī
Mālikī
Ḥanbalī
---
2. What Is a Theological School (Creedal Madhhab)?
A theological school refers to a structured set of beliefs concerning the fundamental principles of faith, such as monotheism (tawḥīd), prophethood, resurrection, divine justice, and leadership (imamate or caliphate).
Key features:
Focus: Beliefs and doctrines
Sources: The Qur’an, Sunnah, and rational theology
Differences occur in core doctrinal principles
Blind imitation (taqlīd) is not acceptable; belief must be based on conviction
Examples:
Twelver Shiʿism (Imāmī)
Ashʿarism
Māturīdism
Muʿtazilism
---
3. Key Differences at a Glance
Aspect Juristic School Theological School
Domain Practice Belief
Subject Legal rulings Doctrines
Nature of differences Secondary issues Foundational beliefs
Taqlīd (imitation) Permissible and required Not permissible
Goal Correct practice Correct belief
---
4. Conclusion
Differences between juristic and theological schools do not indicate division in Islam, but rather reflect diversity in interpreting and explaining the religion. All Islamic schools share the core principles of Islam, while differences lie mainly in methodology and interpretation.