The Balance of Trust in God and Precaution in the Life of Ayatollah Bahjat; Shari'ah as Freedom
Introduction
In conventional understanding, "trust in God" (tawakkul) and "precaution" (ihtiyat) appear to be two incompatible concepts: one is leaving matters to God, the other is clinging to precise boundaries. Ayatollah Bahjat, however, saw them not in opposition but in complementarity. He neither called man to inaction in the name of trust, nor to paralyzing scrupulosity in the name of precaution. The sentence quoted from him precisely delineates this balance: "We should act upon what we know, and pause and exercise precaution regarding what we do not know until it becomes clear; in that case, regret and loss will never find a way to us. If this resolve is firm and established in the servant, God, the Exalted, is more worthy of granting success and assistance." This article seeks to show that in Bahjat's life, the Shari'ah is not a chain, but a framework for liberation from the bondage of doubt and caprice.
Body
First, trust in God (tawakkul)—entrusting the outcome to God after fulfilling one's duty—is not tawākul (inaction under the pretext of trust). In Bahjat's understanding, trust in God is not delegating responsibility to God before fulfilling one's duty; rather, it is entrusting the outcome to Him after exerting all one's capacity and discerning one's obligation. The dhikr "Lā ḥawla wa lā quwwata illā billāh" (There is no power or strength except through God), upon which he placed great emphasis, carries precisely this meaning: the admission that no power exists except through God is not a call to sit idle, but a confession of essential poverty that drives a person to strive. One who knows he has no power does not abandon effort; he takes hold of the Power from whom all powers come.
Second, precaution (ihtiyat) is not scrupulosity (waswās). Precaution in Bahjat's view is a "walking stick," not a wall that blocks the path. He himself walked based on precaution, but this precaution never led to anxious, pathological doubt. The pivotal sentence "pause and exercise precaution regarding what we do not know" draws a clear boundary: precaution applies where one does not know, and for the purpose of arriving at knowledge. Bahjat's precaution was a question that drove a person toward certainty, not a dead end that imprisoned him in doubt. In the narrated tradition, the dhikr "Lā ḥawla wa lā quwwata illā billāh" is also recommended for relief from sorrow and affliction, indicating that this dhikr is a tool of opening, not a cause of passivity.
Third, Shari'ah as freedom. If trust in God is entrusting the outcome to God after fulfilling one's duty, and precaution is clinging to the boundaries of the known until the unknown becomes clear, then what is the Shari'ah? In this view, the Shari'ah is not a collection of restrictive "don'ts"; it is a framework that liberates a person from bondage to two inner enemies: the caprice of the self that drags him in every direction, and paralyzing doubt that nails him in place. One who acts upon what he knows and exercises precaution in what he does not know is no longer a slave to uncertainty; he is free within a clear framework. Bahjat himself said: "Peace is not attained by anything other than trust in God and the remembrance of God." Peace is the fruit of freedom; and freedom is the fruit of living within a framework that liberates a person from inner bondages.
Conclusion
The balance of trust in God and precaution in the life of Ayatollah Bahjat is a prescription for liberation from two traps: the trap of inaction in the name of trust, and the trap of scrupulosity in the name of precaution. With the sentence "acting upon what we know and precaution in what we do not know," he shows a path in which the Shari'ah is not the end of freedom but its beginning. One who implements this balance in his life is neither paralyzed before the unknown, nor does he abandon responsibility under the pretext of trust. He walks within a clear framework, with the power he receives from God. Andthis is the very freedom of which Bahjat spoke.
Next Article
In the next article, we will turn independently to the dhikr "Lā ḥalwla wa lā quwwata illā billāh" in the life of Ayatollah Bahjat—a dhikr he recommended for the treatment of arrogance and ostentation and considered the best dhikr in times of difficulty—and its connection to the confession of powerlessness and opening in life.
Sources
· Bahjat, Muhammad Taqi. Bah Sū-yi Maḥbūb (Toward the Beloved: Instructions and Guidance of Ayatollah Bahjat), p. 28.
· Office of Ayatollah Bahjat. Bahjat al-Duʿāʾ, 2nd ed., pp. 361, 387.
· Dar Maḥḍar-i Bahjat, vol. 2, pp. 245–246.
· Al-Kulaynī, Muhammad ibn Yaʿqūb. Al-Kāfī (narration from Imam al-Ṣādiq (a.s.) regarding the dhikr "Lā ḥawla wa lā quwwata illā billāh").
















